Comments on: The Kirk Report – Is it worth becoming a member? http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/ Trainee Trader provides articles and tutorials related to Forex, Derivatives, Equities and Futures markets. Mon, 19 Dec 2011 22:35:14 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: FatterTapeworm http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-20060 FatterTapeworm Tue, 13 Sep 2011 02:10:34 +0000 http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-20060 If you are going to charge subscribers $100 and sell yourself as a successful trader, then you should make available audited P&L statements for the past five years indicating whether or not you are in fact a successful trader. Maybe he is more of blogger than a trader. How are we to know? Are we supposed to take his word for it? LOL. Please. If you are a truly successful trader, then on a cost benefit basis, it would make no rational sense to waste any time blogging or writing books for that matter. Further, why would you risk divulging your profitable trading system, unless you don't really have one. The only blogger I've ever heard of that vaulted to running a hedge fund is Michael Burry. He eventually netted himself about $100 million betting on the subprime meltdown. You don't see Burry running a blog now. If you are going to charge subscribers $100 and sell yourself as a successful trader, then you should make available audited P&L statements for the past five years indicating whether or not you are in fact a successful trader. Maybe he is more of blogger than a trader. How are we to know? Are we supposed to take his word for it? LOL. Please. If you are a truly successful trader, then on a cost benefit basis, it would make no rational sense to waste any time blogging or writing books for that matter. Further, why would you risk divulging your profitable trading system, unless you don’t really have one. The only blogger I’ve ever heard of that vaulted to running a hedge fund is Michael Burry. He eventually netted himself about $100 million betting on the subprime meltdown. You don’t see Burry running a blog now.

]]> By: Benjamin http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-20053 Benjamin Fri, 05 Aug 2011 23:24:16 +0000 http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-20053 Thanks for your review of the Kirk Report! How do you feel about the service now that you've been a member for another year or so? Personally, I had never heard of him :shock: until he linked to one of my blog articles this morning and I saw a bunch of people coming to my site from his! Thanks for your review of the Kirk Report! How do you feel about the service now that you’ve been a member for another year or so? Personally, I had never heard of him :shock: until he linked to one of my blog articles this morning and I saw a bunch of people coming to my site from his!

]]> By: richard szaro http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-20046 richard szaro Mon, 04 Jul 2011 02:07:57 +0000 http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-20046 i have found all of your commentary to be quite interesting. i have found all of your commentary to be quite interesting.

]]> By: admin http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-12272 admin Mon, 29 Mar 2010 15:42:32 +0000 http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-12272 Thanks for the feedback it is always good to get other users opinions. I did get an email when my subscription was due to expire about the price increase. My understanding was that if you renewed your subscription you would still be charged at the old rate. Thank you for the info about AAII it is worth looking into. Would you mind sharing the link of the forum you have found? Best of luck with the trading. TT Thanks for the feedback it is always good to get other users opinions. I did get an email when my subscription was due to expire about the price increase. My understanding was that if you renewed your subscription you would still be charged at the old rate.

Thank you for the info about AAII it is worth looking into. Would you mind sharing the link of the forum you have found?

Best of luck with the trading.

TT

]]> By: MSG http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-12270 MSG Sun, 28 Mar 2010 23:16:37 +0000 http://www.traineetrader.com/the-kirk-report-is-it-worth-becoming-a-member/#comment-12270 Not worth it. I've been a member for over 2 years and I don't think it's worth the price of admission. He recently jacked up his subscription fees to $100. For that amount, you should just get a lifetime subscription to AAII and follow their stock screens. That's essentially what his stock screen machine is. Just some modified stock screeners that use AAII's database to back test. In the 2 years I've been a member, I have not learned a whole lot. I've actually used another forum that has made me way more money, and that forum is free. And Charles just doesn't respond to your inquiries unless you have access problems. Not worth it. I’ve been a member for over 2 years and I don’t think it’s worth the price of admission. He recently jacked up his subscription fees to $100. For that amount, you should just get a lifetime subscription to AAII and follow their stock screens. That’s essentially what his stock screen machine is. Just some modified stock screeners that use AAII’s database to back test. In the 2 years I’ve been a member, I have not learned a whole lot. I’ve actually used another forum that has made me way more money, and that forum is free. And Charles just doesn’t respond to your inquiries unless you have access problems.

]]>